Teacher-Centered Perennialism Philosophy of Education: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Application

      Niño D. Estolas, M.Ed., LPT

    Perennialism is a timeless philosophy of education that centers on the idea of transmitting a set of enduring, classical knowledge and values to students. It places a strong emphasis on the teacher as the authority figure who imparts this timeless wisdom. 

    In this article, we will delve into the teacher-centered perennialism philosophy of education, explore its advantages and disadvantages, and discuss its application to the teaching and learning process. Additionally, we will introduce some perennialist philosophers and their contributions to this educational philosophy.

(edwardmalia, www.istockphoto.com)

Teacher-Centered Perennialism Philosophy of Education

    Perennialism is rooted in the belief that there exists a body of knowledge that is timeless and universally relevant. This knowledge includes classical works of literature, history, philosophy, and mathematics. 

Key characteristics of teacher-centered perennialism include:

1. Great Books Curriculum: Perennialist education often revolves around the study of "great books" or classic texts from various disciplines. These texts are considered foundational and enduring.
2. Teacher as Authority: In perennialist classrooms, the teacher is seen as the primary authority figure who guides students through the exploration of classical knowledge. The teacher imparts wisdom and fosters intellectual growth.
3. Emphasis on Intellectual Development: Perennialism places a strong emphasis on intellectual development, critical thinking, and analytical skills. Students are encouraged to engage deeply with the content.
4. Moral and Ethical Education: Perennialism often includes a strong moral and ethical component, with an emphasis on character development and the transmission of ethical values.

Advantages of Teacher-Centered Perennialism

1. Cultivation of Critical Thinking: Perennialism encourages students to think critically, analyze complex texts, and engage in deep intellectual discussions.
2. Transmission of Timeless Knowledge: The focus on classic texts ensures that students are exposed to enduring ideas and wisdom that have stood the test of time.
3. Development of Intellectual Virtues: Perennialism promotes the development of intellectual virtues such as curiosity, perseverance, and a love of learning.
4. Moral and Ethical Foundation: The inclusion of moral and ethical education helps students develop a strong sense of values and ethics.

Disadvantages of Teacher-Centered Perennialism

1. Rigidity: Critics argue that perennialism can be rigid and inflexible, with little room for innovation or adaptation to the evolving needs of society.
2. Relevance Concerns: Some argue that the emphasis on classical texts may not always align with the realities of the modern world, potentially leaving students ill-prepared for contemporary challenges.
3. Lack of Diversity: Perennialist curricula often focus on Western classical texts, potentially overlooking the contributions of other cultures and perspectives.
4. Limited Student Engagement: The teacher-centered approach may not always engage students effectively, leading to passive learning rather than active participation.

Application to Teaching and Learning

    Implementing perennialism in the classroom involves the selection and study of classic texts, fostering critical thinking, and emphasizing intellectual development. Teachers play a central role as guides and facilitators of meaningful discussions and explorations of timeless ideas. While this approach can be intellectually enriching, educators must also strike a balance by incorporating modern perspectives and ensuring that the curriculum remains relevant to the students' lives.

Notable Perennialism Philosophers and Their Contributions

1. Mortimer J. Adler: Adler was a prominent proponent of perennialism and is known for his work on "The Great Books of the Western World" collection. He advocated for a core curriculum based on classic texts.
2. Robert Hutchins: Hutchins, a philosopher and educator, played a key role in promoting the "great books" approach to education. He believed in a core curriculum that centered on classical works.
3. Allan Bloom: Bloom is known for his influential book, "The Closing of the American Mind," which critiqued modern education and championed the study of classic texts.

Application in the Classroom

Perennialism is an educational philosophy that emphasizes the enduring ideas and knowledge that have shaped human civilization. It advocates for a curriculum centered around classical literature, history, philosophy, and mathematics. 

Here are some activities that teachers may apply in a classroom following the perennialist approach:

1. Socratic Dialogues:

Engage students in Socratic dialogues to encourage critical thinking and deep philosophical discussions. This method involves posing open-ended questions to stimulate thoughtful reflection and analysis of classic texts (Hansen, 2012).

2. Great Books Discussions:

Conduct discussions centered around classic literary works, historical texts, and philosophical treatises. Encourage students to explore timeless ideas and engage in intellectual discourse (Adler & Wolff, 2000).

3. Debates on Universal Ideas:

Organize debates on universal concepts such as justice, morality, truth, and beauty. This encourages students to articulate and defend their viewpoints based on foundational principles (Cahn, 2005).

4. Analysis of Primary Sources:

Have students analyze primary sources from different historical periods and philosophical traditions. This helps them gain a deeper understanding of the intellectual foundations of human civilization (Freschi, 2019).

5. Classical Language Studies:

Introduce students to classical languages like Latin or Greek. This allows them to explore original texts and gain insights into the linguistic roots of Western thought (Duckworth, 2012).

6. Philosophy Circles:

Implement philosophy circles, where students gather to discuss philosophical questions, dilemmas, and ethical issues. This promotes critical thinking and intellectual inquiry (Lipman & Sharp, 2003).

7. Historical Simulations:

Conduct historical simulations or reenactments to immerse students in pivotal moments of history. This experiential learning approach helps them gain a deeper appreciation for the historical context of ideas (Kaplan, 2016).

8. Comparative Studies:

Encourage students to compare and contrast ideas, philosophies, and works from different time periods and cultures. This promotes a broader understanding of human thought and civilization (Noddings, 1995).

In a Philippine setting, incorporating perennialism into education can be achieved through various activities that emphasize the enduring ideas and knowledge that have shaped human civilization. 

Here are some activities that students can engage in:

1. Socratic Seminars on Filipino Literature:

Encourage students to engage in Socratic seminars focused on classic Filipino literary works. This promotes critical thinking, deepens understanding of the texts, and encourages students to explore timeless ideas within the context of Philippine culture (e.g., discussions on Jose Rizal's novels).

2. Exploration of Historical Texts and Documents:

Have students analyze primary sources related to Philippine history, such as historical documents, letters, and speeches. This allows them to gain insights into the intellectual foundations and key ideas that have shaped the nation.

3. Debates on Universal Values in Filipino Context:

Organize debates centered around universal values like justice, morality, and freedom, applying these concepts to specific Filipino historical events or contemporary issues. This helps students understand how enduring ideas apply in the context of their own country.

4. Study of Filipino Philosophers and Thinkers:

Introduce students to Filipino philosophers and thinkers who have contributed to the intellectual heritage of the Philippines. Explore their writings and ideas, encouraging students to reflect on their relevance in contemporary society.

5. Comparative Studies of Filipino and World Cultures:

Encourage students to compare and contrast Filipino culture, traditions, and values with those of other civilizations. This activity promotes a deeper understanding of the uniqueness and universality of human experiences.

6. Philippine Language and Literature Studies:

Include the study of classical Filipino literature, poetry, and language in the curriculum. This enables students to appreciate the rich literary heritage of the Philippines and understand the cultural context of classic texts.

7. Ethical Dilemmas in Philippine History:

Present students with ethical dilemmas based on significant events in Philippine history. Encourage them to analyze and debate the moral implications of decisions made by historical figures.

8. Historical Role-Playing and Reenactments:

Organize historical role-playing activities or reenactments to immerse students in specific events or time periods in Philippine history. This experiential learning approach provides a deeper appreciation for the historical context of enduring ideas.

By engaging in these activities, students can develop a deeper appreciation for the enduring ideas and knowledge that have shaped Philippine society and civilization. They will also gain critical thinking skills and a broader understanding of their cultural heritage.

Scientific Bases of Perennialism in the Classroom

Perennialism, as an educational philosophy, draws on several scientific and philosophical principles to support its approach to teaching and learning. 

Here are some of the scientific bases of perennialism in the classroom:

1. Cognitive Development Theory:

Perennialism aligns with cognitive development theories, particularly the work of Jean Piaget. Piaget emphasized the importance of exposing students to abstract and formal operational thinking, which is characteristic of adolescence. Perennialist curriculum, with its focus on classic texts and enduring ideas, provides opportunities for students to engage in abstract thinking and develop their cognitive abilities (Piaget, 1970).

2. Schema Theory:

Perennialism is grounded in the idea that students should be exposed to foundational knowledge and concepts that form the basis for further learning. Schema theory suggests that individuals organize new information by integrating it with existing knowledge structures. By focusing on enduring ideas, perennialism provides a framework for students to build and expand their mental schemas (Anderson & Pearson, 1984).

3. Transfer of Learning:

Perennialist education aims to equip students with broad, transferable knowledge and skills. Research indicates that students are more likely to transfer their learning to new contexts when they have a deep understanding of fundamental concepts. By studying enduring ideas, students are better prepared to apply their knowledge to a wide range of situations (Perkins & Salomon, 1992).

4. Long-Term Retention and Mastery Learning:

The emphasis on classic texts and enduring ideas in perennialism encourages deep learning and mastery. Research in educational psychology suggests that spaced repetition and revisiting key concepts over time lead to long-term retention of knowledge (Bjork & Bjork, 2011). Perennialism aligns with this principle by focusing on timeless concepts that students revisit throughout their education.

5. Cultural and Historical Significance:

Perennialism recognizes the cultural and historical significance of classic texts and enduring ideas. This aligns with research in anthropology and history, which emphasizes the importance of understanding the cultural and historical context of ideas and knowledge (Geertz, 1973).

 While perennialism may not be explicitly tied to contemporary cognitive science, its emphasis on foundational knowledge and enduring ideas aligns with principles of cognitive development, learning theory, and the organization of knowledge in the human mind. This makes it a relevant and valuable educational philosophy that can contribute to effective teaching and learning.

 

References:

1. Adler, M. J. (1990). The Paideia Proposal: An Educational Manifesto. Touchstone.
2. Hutchins, R. M. (1952). The great conversation: The substance of a liberal education. Encyclopaedia Britannica.
3. Bloom, A. (1987). The Closing of the American Mind: How Higher Education Has Failed Democracy and Impoverished the Souls of Today's Students. Simon & Schuster.
4. Nash, R. J. (2010). Liberating Scholarly Writing: The Power of Personal Narrative. Teachers College Press.
5. Sowell, T. (1983). Inside American Education: The Decline, The Deception, The Dogmas. Free Press.
6. Hansen, D. T. (2012). "Teaching and Learning with the Great Books: The Socratic Method." University of Chicago Press.
7. Adler, M. J., & Wolff, P. (2000). "The Great Books: Second Year Course." Encyclopedia Britannica.
8. Cahn, S. M. (2005). "Classics of Western Philosophy." Hackett Publishing.
9. Freschi, E. (2019). "What is a Primary Source? A Simple Explanation for Students." Teaching History, 174, 31-34.
10. Duckworth, E. R. (2012). "Ancient Rome and Greece." Bloomsbury Publishing.
11. Lipman, M., & Sharp, A. M. (2003). "Growing up with philosophy camps." Childhood and Philosophy, 4(7), 129-146.
12. Kaplan, R. D. (2016). "Teaching World History: An Idea Guide." Routledge.
13. Noddings, N. (1995). "Philosophy of Education." Westview Press.
14. Anderson, R. C., & Pearson, P. D. (1984). "A schema-theoretic view of basic processes in reading comprehension." Handbook of reading research, 1, 255-291.
15. Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). "Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning." Psychology and the Real World: Essays Illustrating Fundamental Contributions to Society, 56-64.
16. Geertz, C. (1973). "The interpretation of cultures: Selected essays." Basic books.
17. Perkins, D. N., & Salomon, G. (1992). "Transfer of learning." International encyclopedia of education, 2, 6452-6457.
18. Piaget, J. (1970). "Genetic Epistemology." Columbia University Press

Teacher-Centered Perennialism Philosophy of Education: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Application by Niño D. Estolas is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Based on a work at https://universal-library-resources.blogspot.com/.